Which Is Better: Solid Or Mesh Pool Cover? | A Breakdown Of Each

Solid VS Mesh Pool Cover

It is ideal for covering the pool after doing all the appropriate closing actions. Several methods are known to cover and protect indoor pools in winter, but the proper technique in selecting the best pool cover may not yet be known to new pool owners.

Which is better: solid or mesh pool cover? Mesh covering filters large waste and small particles into the water. A solid cover stops all things from entering the pool water. Which is better depends on what you can commit and what you need.

Since selecting the perfect cover entails various factors, you should make sure you have the crucial details. I will list down all the advantages and disadvantages of solid and mesh pool covers.

Solid And Mesh Pool Cover

You can choose between a solid pool cover and a mesh pool cover to protect your pool. These options are available this winter to cover and protect your in-ground pool.

Mesh Cover

Winter coverings are essential for winter protection, and if you live in a snowfall location are perfect. Mesh covering is porous to prevent puddles on the surface of the cover. It melts snow, melts ice, and rain from dropping through the pool cover.

The overnight mesh cover also prevents the entry of waste and foreign objects into the pool water. However, it allows for the passage of smaller waste parts.

In the springtime, you can easily clean waste particles using a vacuum in the pool. Mesh coverings are cheaper than solid pool coverings and lightweight, making installation and removal easier.

Winterization Chemistry

1. Rising pH

pH will eventually reach its maximum of roughly 8.2. However, you can ignore pH if you winter unless acidic chlorine-like trichloride is still flowing and feeding.

Ignore the pH and allow it to increase up to its pH definition by around 8.2. It is the perfect time to cut the system off and no longer chlorinate.

2. Dilution

Nero hardness, cyanuric acid, salt, and TDS are present in the rain and snow. The rainfall is very low on the LSI. It can have distilled water, diluting the chemistry of your pool over several months.

The hardness of calcium, CYA, and TDS will all decline throughout winter. Of course, this is not all bad news because the reduction of CYA helps more than one chemical.

But is calcium reduced? It can be troubling during the winter, as calcium is your best friend to keep the LSI balance in cold water.

3. Safety

The mesh cover does not collect water. It is less susceptible to being moist and is less susceptible to drowning.

4. Installation

Mesh covers are substantially lighter than solid coverings, and often a single person can install them. That’s why homeowners commonly opt for this cover when they wish to close their pools for the winter.

5. Costs

Mesh covers are considerably cheaper to buy and install than solid coverings. Depending on the form and size of the pond, the mesh cover costs between $999.99 and $2,999.99.

6. Pumps

Mesh pool coverings allow water to enter the pool through the surface. It is a good thing since there will be no water collection above the pool cover.

7. Water

Mesh covers filter huge waste and small particles that can go into the pool water. In this respect, you can clean the sediments on the ground when you reopen the swimming pool.

8. Appearance

Mesh pool coverings are fine, tight woven fibers that allow the passage of water but not waste. They, therefore, have a more textured appearance than a solid cover.

9. Usability

Mesh covers are considerably smoother than solid coverings since they do not compose any solid vinyl fibers. It is the reason why a single individual is frequently able to install and delete them.

Advantages Of Mesh Cover

  • No pool puddles limit the chance for child or animal mishaps.
  • Leaves and waste stay dry and smooth.
  • Rainwater and snowmelt replenish the evaporated water.
  • Less costly than robust coverings.
  • Easy to install and uninstall lightweight material.
  • No sump pump is required to remove steady water from the top of the lid.
  • It can keep out all the waste except fine particles of dust and causes a breeze to spring from the pool.
  • It has a tight weave of Polypropylene heavy-duty fibers to last for a long time.
  • Rainwater and snowmelt through the mesh. The standing water will not weigh down the pool cover.

Disadvantages Of Mesh Cover

  • Sunlight may enter the swimming pool to support bacteria and algae growth.
  • It allows fine particles to enter the swimming pool. When you remove the during springtime, you have to vacuum the pool water.

Mesh Pool Cover Types

The difference in the UV radiation of the blocks is the difference between mesh cover kinds in particular.

The more UV prevention there is, the lower the growth of bacteria and algae. It implies that it only needs a few chemicals in addition to your swimming pool.

Standard Mesh Standard Mesh Safety Cover 

This kind of cover is the cheapest security cover. For pools in winter climates that do not have considerable snowfall, this safety cover is the best.

Furthermore, the bulk of its maintenance is for people in the springtime.

  • Easy to install and remove lightweight
  • Safety cover best value
  • UV blockage of 89-91%

High Shade Mesh

The mesh cover is of higher quality and is highly UV-blocked. This sort of cover has a tighter weave. It limits the growth of algae by 99 percent of sunlight. It makes spring cleaning easier than an ordinary mesh cover.

For folks in the springtime who wish to keep up the bulk of their work, this is the best one for you. This safety cover is best suited to mild to moderate winter conditions with modest snowfall.

  • Sturdy and lightweight for ease of installation and removal.
  • The blocks restrict algae development by 99 percent of the sunlight.
  • Most popular national mesh security cover

Solid Pool Cover

The solid winter cover is almost airtight and can keep the pool from entering dirt, water, trash, and sunlight. Blocked sunlight prevents the growth in the pool throughout the autumn and winter months of algae and other creatures.

A solid cover for the winter pool assures your water in the springtime is as wonderful as it was throughout the fall.

You will need to remove the built-in water and melted snow from the cover surface. For that, you will need a deck pump. The solid cover also prevents the introduction of children and animals into the pool water. It is resistant to each other’s weights.

Winterization Chemistry

1. pH suppression

Carbon dioxide cannot escape. There is no equalization in the atmosphere above the pool. Your pH can only increase that high. Of course, unless the cover is loose enough to let air sneak out from under it.

The pH at which you close is the pH at which the water remains. But it will change if an arsenal pool has a cemented surface.

pH can only rise with solid cover if it is forceful. The natural methods have been taken for the pH to go up by itself.

With a solid cover, you will no longer need as much calcium hardness. It will not dilute. Your pH will not be able to reach its ceiling again.

Wintering a pool with firm shelving keeps LSI equilibrium over winter independent of the surface type of the pool. Higher calcium hardness is desirable. However, you may need more alkalinity in a solid pool cover rather than rely on the growing pH.

2. No dilution

Snow and rain can’t enter the pool to dilute the hardness of the calcium. Thus the chemistry with which you close the swimming pool is almost the chemistry of winter’s chemistry.

It can be good if you want to keep calcium hardness high. However, it is harmful if you rely on rain to help dilute things, such as cyanuric acid (CYA).

It means that you have to delay the closing day. The purpose is to keep the temperatures of the coldest water with enough calcium and alkalinity.

If you continue to provide pool servicing in the winter, you have to make chemistry adjustments during the off-season each month.

3. Safety

Solid surfaces gather water on the surface. Water may constitute a drowning risk to children and animals if adult owners do not drain the swimming pool.

Therefore, when employing a solid cover, the pump is required. The vinyl can also be slippery.

4. Installation

Solid covers are heavier and thus harder to install. They often need two or more persons to correct the pool cover position. You may have to employ a professional firm if you don’t have the labor at home.

5. Costs

A solid cover costs between $1,799.99 and $3,599.99 for the same shape and size as a mesh cover. So on average, it is around $600.

The first installation of any pool cover will cost between $500.50 and $1,000.99, depending on the size of the pool. Solid pool cover installation costs between $99.99 and $499.99.

Solid pool covers costing closer to $500 and meshes closer to $100. Again, the cost will depend on the size and shape of the pool.

6. Pumps

A solid cover allows the water to accumulate and puddle in the middle. Therefore, a pump is necessary to evacuate the water.

Part of the expense of the solid cover is the addition of the pump. Automatic pumps are available. They can switch themselves when the water reaches a specified depth, although manual pumps are frequently less expensive.

You must operate the pump with a manual pump to remove the water from the cover.

7. Water

The main advantage of a solid cover is that nothing, even water, may enter the pool via the pool cover. Solid covers prevent all sunlight that prevents the growth of algae.

8. Appearance

The solid pool covering has the look of plastic or vinyl with no holes. It’s robust throughout and fluid to the touch.

9. Usability

Solid covers need at least two people, both to move from one area to another. The purpose of this is to achieve the required tension when installed. Many people choose to use solid coverings for professional installation.

Advantages Of Solid Pool Cover

  • There is no evaporation of water and chemical products from the pool, which means less work and fewer substances utilized during spring opening.
  • Some solid roofings have mesh drain panels that allow water from the roof to drain.
  • It provides a robust barrier between the pool and the surroundings.
  • It prevents the entry of fine particles into the pool water.
  • Maintains outdoor sunlight to avoid winter growth of any bacteria or algae.
  • Super robust structures will not tear, keep your pool clean and your family safe—super-strong construction.

Disadvantages Of Solid Pool Cover

  • Solid covers are heavier and need to be installed and removed a little longer than mesh covers.
  • Without mesh drain panels, pump pumps are necessary. Sump pumps remove steady water from the pool cover and prevent slippery or icy surface mishaps.

Solid Pool Cover Types

Solid Safety Cover With Pump

A solid pump safety cover offers all the advantages of a robust drainage safety cover. The large kahuna of safety covers is an automatic pump solid safety cover.

However, your pool doesn’t drain any water. The pool cover will instead pump all the pool water.

No run-off water enters the pool, and you have a spring opening with a cleaner pool.

AKA has spent less time and money on making your swimming pool ready when it comes. It is not suitable in temperate or severe cold climates since the pump may freeze.

  • In the off-season, there is nothing in the pool, not even the sun.
  • Minimum upkeep in the springtime
  • UV blocking 100 percent

Solid Safety Cover With Drain

The amount of water on the cover will be fewer with a sturdy safety cover with a drain.

One thing I don’t like about this is how the drain drains the pool water. If you wish to stretch the maintenance through wintertime and springtime, this is the best alternative.

  • Less maintenance in both winter and spring
  • UV blocking 100 percent


A mesh cover is a way to go if you aim to have your backyard secure. If you want to maintain your backyard safe, algae-free, and consistent chemical levels, then the solid cover is the best option!

So then again, the best pool cover for your swimming pool will depend on what you need.

Recent Posts